THE INVENTION OF WINGS (2014)
Sue Monk
Kidd
Viking,
ISBN 978-0670024780, 384 pp.
* * * *
If you took Kathryn Stockett’s The Help out of the 20th
century and set it during slavery, you might end up with something like The Invention of Wings and you’d get a much
better book in the bargain. Sue Monk Kidd’s novel is similarly based on an
improbable black/white friendship. She takes us to Charleston, South Carolina
in 1803, the year the 11-year-old daughter of a wealthy plantation family
received an unorthodox birthday present: her own slave, 10-year-old Hetty
(known as Handful in the slave quarters). The birthday girl in question was
Sarah Grimké, who shocked her family by trying to free Hetty on the grounds
that it was immoral to own slaves. At 11, Sarah was too young to carry out her
will, as she would be in adolescence when she insisted she wanted to be a
lawyer, but as an adult Sarah Grimké would become a pioneering abolitionist and
feminist.
Kidd takes us inside the slave
quarters, where we feel the horrors, smell the smells, and vicariously
experience yearnings for freedom. There is no happy slave pabulum in this
novel; its very title references an African story told by Hetty’s mother
Charlotte of how their ancestors developed wings to fly from danger. Charlotte
is the Grimké family seamstress and she screws on her compliant face around
Mary, the tyrannical mistress of the Grimké household, but privately she
reminds Sarah that she promised to free her daughter and intends to hold her to
that promise.
The novel shows how Sarah and Hetty
developed an unbalanced friendship—one in which it’s not always clear if Sarah
is being true to her principles when she does things such as defy the law by
teaching Hetty to read, or merely using Hetty as an outlet for a rebellious
spirit she’s too scared to exercise around her strict parents. The theme of
real versus imagined rebellion is driven home though the overlapping story of
Denmark Vesey, a free black man who tried to start a slave uprising in 1822.
Coming just three years after Sarah accompanied her dying father north against
her will, we begin to wonder if she is all talk and no action. Up to that
point, her single biggest act of free will was to insist that she
unconventionally be named her sister Angelina’s godmother when the latter was born
in 1805.
We know, of course, that Sarah does
break out. After numerous trips back to Philadelphia she became a Quaker
minister—an act of feminist pluck that sabotaged her marriage plans—and, in
1827, went back go Charleston to take Angelina away from the South and into a
life of abolitionist and feminist agitation. (Angelina married another famed
abolitionist, Theodore Weld.) This part of the story is documented; Kidd’s
skill lies in imaging the lives of the slaves left behind based on fragmentary
evidence, and in stitching history and imagination into a brightly colored
fictional quilt that both enlightens and entertains. (A quilt plays a key part
in the novel, by the way.)
Among the novel’s many revelations
is its focus on the slave culture: its inner codes, its folklore, its acts of
everyday rebellion, and the lengths to which slaves went to preserve dignity in
the face of barbaric injustices. Without knocking us over the head, Kidd also
challenges the ingrained Southern myth that Stockett perpetuated in The Help—that many black people came to
love and cherish their masters. Hetty and Charlotte, for example, knew that
even as a child Sarah wanted the best for them, but they also knew you couldn’t
trust white folks and that there were huge structural obstacles in the way of
good intentions. Again without being overt about it, Kidd raises the question
of whether true friendship is even possible when power relations are
skewed—something Sarah discovers in her life among male Quakers, who were sure
that slavery was wrong, but were pretty comfortable with patriarchy.
Let me emphasize that this is a
novel, not a history book. Kidd demonstrates great skill in developing
scenarios, inventing dialogue, and filling in history’s gaps. The novel runs
over 380 pages but, like the wings in its title, it flies. Add this book to
other recent efforts such as The Secret
Life of Bees and The Mermaid Chair,
and it’s clear that Ms. Kidd is poised to take her place among the leading
ladies of letters.—Rob Weir
Warning: I did not
read or listen to the Oprah Book Club version of this novel, but there are many
warnings that it should be avoided. Apparently Winfrey interjects her own
commentary to the print and audio versions in an intrusive manner that breaks
the narrative. Look for versions that say “unmarked” or “without commentary.”