Like/Life: Photography by Martine Gutierrez
Promise of the Infinite: Joan Jonas
Afterlives of Objects/Conflict and Commemoration
Mount Holyoke Afire
Mount Holyoke Museum
of Art
Through June 2019
Readers of this blog know that I often prefer smaller, more
intimate exhibitions to brain-numbing blockbusters. Is there such a thing as
too small? Yes. Several shows at Mount Holyoke College (MHC) cross that line.
Let's start with what Mount Holyoke does right. MHC has
always prided itself on being a teaching museum that uses its collection to
supplement what takes place in the classroom. An exhibit titled Afterlives of Objects uses the permanent
collection as "biographies;" that is, it discusses the object, its
origins, and how it ended up in a college art museum. Good idea. The most
powerful statements concern adaptive reuse of materials, such as what appears
from a distance to be an African-style mask, but which is actually an
assemblage of shoes. The overall theme, though, is an important one in an age
where hard questions are asked about the appropriateness of collection methods.
Does a Mende dance mask teach us about traditional cultures in modern Sierra
Leone, or does it exoticize in patronizing ways?
This struck me as a much more profound strain of inquiry
than another teaching exhibit Conflict
& Commemoration. I breezed through this one because it seemed so
obvious. It purports to look at loss and the aftereffects of war. The paintings
and objects chosen tell us little that we don't know. The message is that war
is a bad thing that kills, destroys, and has lasting impact. Duh! Other than
neo-fascists and Nietzsche junkies, who would argue otherwise? The exhibit
mostly sidesteps the question of whether conflict is necessary in the first
place.
The museum's current featured exhibits underwhelm.
Eighty-two-year-old visual artist Joan Jonas, a Mount Holyoke alum, is
considered by many to be the "Mother of all Performance Artists."
Perhaps she is, but this form of art runs into meta problems when it's on
display in a museum. Put simply, once stripped of its very
nature–performance–the artistry is easily lost. How interesting is grainy
footage of naked people standing in a row while other semi-naked people don
mirrored assemblages that refract the view of the lineup? Not very.
The featured MHC show at present is Life/Look, a collection of photographs by Martine Gutierrez (b.
1989), a transgendered Latinx. Hers is a thought-provoking display, but it's
also a classic one-trick pony. Gutierrez wishes us to analyze our own gaze, as
well as explore gender roles and boundaries. To that end, she poses
flesh-and-blood women–often dressed in retro style–in a variety of poses: languid,
sensual, whimsical, vaguely erotic, ironic…. She juxtaposes her living subjects
with life-life mannequins that call attention to the Life/Look title of the show.
I liked Gutierrez's work, but the show is too small and is
tucked away in vest-pocket-sized gallery. The images are strong but once you
"get" it, there's not much more to whet the appetite. Her past work
provokes thoughts on race, fashion, disembodiment, and fluid sexuality. She infers
these themes in Life/Look as well,
but the show's small size reduces Gutierrez's politics to the realm of novelty.
In a word, what we need is: more.
I also couldn't escape the fact that the most extensive
feature show is "Mount Holyoke Afire," which shows the aftermath of
three disastrous campus fires. The one in 1896 destroyed the college's original
seminary building. Those in 1912 and 1922 also wiped out some of the college's
past. It is a nicely done exhibit that looks at those who battled the blazes as
well as campus remembrances of the fires. Would that several of the other shows
been equally well curated.
Rob Weir
No comments:
Post a Comment