PAINTED LADIES (2010)
By Robert B. Parker
G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 291 pages.
★★★
When I was gleaning at the League of Women Voters book sale, I came across Painted Ladies, a Robert Parker novel I hadn’t read. For most, “painted ladies” conjures a refurbished row of gingerbread Victorian mansions in San Francisco. This novel never leaves Spenser’s stomping grounds in Boston.
Spenser is a wisecracking private detective for whom the discipline of being a cop was too restrictive. He’s done well, but PIs take work where they can find it. Beware of simple assignments. All Spenser must do to collect a fat fee is sit in the car while Walford University Professor Ashton Prince makes a ransom-for-stolen-art exchange. The picture in question is Franz Hermenzoon’s Lady with a Finch, which was pilfered from the Hammond Museum. Prince is an expert on Renaissance Low Country* art, an advisor to the Hammond, and adroit at forensic art (analyzing works to ascertain they are not counterfeit).
Boston’s Storrow Drive wends along the Charles River and is crisscrossed by elevated bridges. The thieves holding the painting pull a fast one; their car is parked on a bridge above and they demand that Spenser stay in the car while Prince alone climbs the stairs to hand over the ransom money. Spenser advises Ashton to call it off, but Prince is overly anxious. He is given a package that blows up and sends pieces of Prince to kingdom come.
From this point on Spenser is working pro bono at his own insistence. He disliked Prince at first glance, but he’s PO’d that someone killed his client. An angry Spenser is a determined Spenser. A lot about the painting theft and assassination doesn’t add up. Why is Walford University only mildly upset by it? Why does the Walford administration ban Spenser (as if!) from the campus? Why is the Hammond Museum content to collect the insurance rather than investigate further? Why would the insurance company pay out millions without a thorough inquiry? Who are two tattooed thugs who twice try to eliminate Spenser, once by blowing up his bed?
Prince doesn’t pass muster either. Why is such an acknowledged art expert still teaching at Walford rather than one of the Ivies? What about his reputation for having sex with his students and his wife’s indifference to it? Hawk is out of the country, so Spenser leans on local law enforcement to cut through stonewalls and red tape. Old frenemy Matthew Quirk, a humorless Boston Police Department homicide investigator is on the case, as is Spenser’s buddy Captain Healy of the Massachusetts State Police. When various elites threaten to sue Spenser, he smells corruption. He can’t prove it, but he solicits help in the sexy form of Rita Fiore, the best lawyer in Boston. She has long been in lust with Spenser, but she knows that Spenser won’t cheat on his longtime lover Susan Silverman. More importantly, though she’s made scads of money, she shares Spenser’s disrespect for new money and snobs. With Rita on his side, Spenser will stay on the case, if he’s not killed first.
If elements of the main plot sound vaguely familiar, Robert Parker might be one of the reasons. It has echoes of the 1990 theft at the Gardner Museum in which 13 works, including a Rembrandt, were taken. Parker invented Franz Hermenzoon, but that surname was Rembrandt’s middle name. In a coincidence, Donna Tartt’s 2014 Pulitzer Price-winning novel The Goldfinch also involved Low Country art, though her 17th century painter Carel Fabrites and The Goldfinch were real.
Robert Parker died in 2010, the year this novel came out. (He had another in the can that was published posthumously). I enjoyed Painted Ladies–largely because I love Spenser’s smart aleck quips and irreverence–but objectively this is not one of the great Spenser novels. It feels a bit rushed and is cramped with trails to follow–snooty rich college students, Nazi stolen Art, Auschwitz, saving people Spenser would rather not, a foundation, assumed identities–and too many seemingly disinterested parties to ring true. Was Parker sick, rushing to finish his final book, or tiring of the entire franchise? Just one more mystery.
Rob Weir
* If you’ve forgotten your geography lessons, Low Country references Europe’s “Benelux” nations (Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg). For the record, there is a painting titled Lady with a Finch, but from the hand of Scotland’s John Graham-Gilbert (1794-1866). It’s in the Glasgow Museum of Art.













