7/10/13

Annalivia Goes Down Easy (Too Easy at Times)

-->
 ANNALIVIA
The Same Way Down
* * *

“Snag,” the midway point of Annalivia’s new nine-track Kickstarter-funded CD, is an original tune from Flynn Cohen that sounds like variations of the famed Irish tune “The Little Beggarman” as done by an Appalachian string band. It encapsulates the ways in which this Boston-based quartet blends Celtic, bluegrass, and Americana influences. Appropriately, the album opens with “False Sir John,” a jaunty arrangement for two fiddles and Liz Simmons’ sweet voice that’s a southern Appalachian variant of older English ballad. The albums also closes with a traditional, “Turtle Dove,” which is evocative of Alison Krauss’s cover of the gospel song “Down to the River to Pray.” The Same Way Down often leaves you wondering if you’re in Asheville or County Antrim. Fiddlers Emerald Rae and Mariel Vandersteel have a definite flair for old-timey sounds, but mandolin/guitar wizard Flynn likes to dislocate us. The “New Mown Meadow,” for instance, sounds like something from Jay Ungar’s set list; that is, except for Cohen’s nouveau Celtic bridge to the breakdown finish. Think you got him pegged? The very next track finds Cohen singing “Bright Sunny South” and, title aside, it too is ambiguous–the mood is south of the Mason-Dixon Line, but his lead is where a hint of twang meets northern reediness.

This is a goes-down-easy album, which is both its strength and, perhaps, a small drawback. Liz Simmons handles most of the songs and hers is a voice of great beauty and delicacy. If “Restless for a While” reminds you of Crooked Still, the effect is magnified by Aoife O’Donovan’s harmonies. Simmons... Krauss… O’Donovan… Three glorious sopranos, but each is quiet, fragile, and high. I’d like to see the band add Cohen’s voice into the mix more dramatically to add contrast, especially to give grit to the harmonies and bite to the darker songs. Even roses need thorns.   --Rob Weir


No comments: